Women health
*Women health>>>Naturopathy

Why do doctors hate naturopathy?


Why is there such a strong, cold disconnect whenever you mention the "N" word (naturopathy) to medical doctors? My girlfriend and her mom have seen naturopaths for years, and whenever they even hint at something they were told by one to an MD, the doc clams up, or tells them (politely or not) that it's all bullshit/malarkey/witchdoctory/etc..

Why the strong resentment?

And please, if you're a rabid follower of naturopathy, spare me any conspiracy theories and hate-based reactions. Ideally, I'd like the opinions of MDs, if possible.

Thanks.

I am an MD.

Allopathic medicine (the evidence-based medical science practiced by MDs) accepts only diagnoses and treatments that are supported by controlled scientific research. We only give advice and treatments that we can prove are effective.

MDs do not say that alternative heath remedies (naturopathy, chiropractic kineseology, etc.) are automatically shams. In each case, either the evidence supports the treatment (accupuncture is shown to help with chronic pain syndromes), it is harmful (green tea extract for weight loss can cause a stroke in patients with hypertension) or there is just no research or proof either way.

The last scenario is most common. Naturopaths often recommend treatments that have not undergone controlled trials. They make health recommendations based on personal experience, anecdotal stories, gut instinct, commonly accepted perception... anything except evidence.

In summary, MDs do not hate naturopaths. We do not trust or recommend treatments that cannot be proven to be safe and effective. The moment naturopaths agree to use only herbal remedies that have undergone controlled trials, you will see MDs starting to embrace them (and even recommend their treatments).

Tags
Menopause Menstrual Disorders Metabolic Syndrome Migraine Multiple Sclerosis Naturopathy Nutrition Incontinence Infertility Irritable Bowel Syndrome
Related information
  • Why do doctors hate naturopathy?

    I am an MD. Allopathic medicine (the evidence-based medical science practiced by MDs) accepts only diagnoses and treatments that are supported by controlled scientific research. We only give adv...

  • M.D. that practices naturopathy/homeopathy/alterna鈥?medicine?

    Aloha We've got a fantastic nationwide network of the kind of MD you're looking for at American Holistic Medical Association www.holisticmedicine.org I've been a member fo...

  • Reliability of Naturopathy?

    Whether or not naturopathy can help depends on what your problem is. Neither allopathic nor naturopathic medicine can cure everything -- if it could, no one would ever die! However, naturopathy is ...

  • How long would I have to go to school after high school to be a naturopathy?

    It depends on where you live. You should check out your options in New York. In the country where I live, it is a 4 year course and medical school to become an MD is only a 6 year course, instead o...

  • What are your thoughts on the career choice of naturopathy? And tell me why you have that opinion.?

    I am a naturopath. I am very happy to have chosen this field. I see my job as largely one of educating patients and the public about ways to stay healthy and get healthier instead of just the pill-...

  • How much opportunity would a person who chooses to be a naturopathy have in the area in and around New York?

    Normally a great chance. But with jobs hard to find it might take a while longer.

    ...
  • If a person received their (N.D.) Doctor of Naturopathy are they considered a practitioner?

    It completely depends on the state you choose to practice in (if naturopathy is liscenced) and more importantly, if you go to an accredited naturopathy school (of which there are only 6 in the US)....

  • Can Naturopathy and ayurvedic medicine cure stage 4 pancreatic cancer without chemotheraphy?

    No, they can't unfortunately. Those therapies are as equally ineffective as chemotherapy in this dreadful disease when stage IV. Sorry. God bless, best wishes

    ...
  •    

    Health Categories--Copyright/IP Policy--Contact Webmaster
    The information on whfhhc.com is provided for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.